Liddell Laboratories

The Best Sunscreens List

HH = Health Hazard; SH = Sun Hazard; OS = Overall Score
Rank
Product (formulation year)
HH
SH
OS
1.
UV Natural Sport SPF 30+ (2007)
1
0
0
2.
Badger SPF 30 (2007)
1
0
1
3.
Peter Thomas Roth Titanium Dioxide Sunblock (SPF 30) (2006)
2
0
1
4.
Lavera Sun Screen Neutral SPF 40 (2007)
2
0
1
5.
Vanicream Sunscreen Sport SPF 35 (2006)
2
0
1
6.
Mustela Bebe High Protection Sun Lotion, SPF 50 (2007)
3
0
1
7.
Mustela Bebe High Protection Sun Lotion (SPF 50) (2006)
3
0
1
8.
OBAGI NuDerm Nu-Derm Physical UV Block Step Six (SPF 32) (2006)
3
0
1
9.
Peter Thomas Roth Titanium Dioxide Sunblock (SPF 30) (2006)
3
0
1
10.
Vanicream Sunscreen for Sensitive Skin (SPF 60) (2006)
3
0
1
11.
Blue Lizard Australian Suncream, SPF 30, Sensitive (2007)
3
0
1
12.
Peter Thomas Roth Ultra Lite Titanium Dioxide Sunblock (SPF 30) (2006)
3
0
1
13.
Glycolix Elite Sunscreen (SPF 30) (2006)
3
0
1
14.
Blue Lizard Australian Suncream, SPF 30, Baby (2007)
3
0
1
15.
Blue Lizard Suncream, Sensitive Skin (SPF 30) (2006)
3
0
1
16.
Jason Natural Cosmetics sunbrellas SPF 30+ Mineral Based physical sunblock (2007) 3
0
1
17.
Fallene Total Block Cotz Waterproof Sunblock (SPF 58 (now in a tube)) (2005)
4
0
1
18.
Elta Gold UV Sport Waterproof (SPF 50) (2006)
4
0
1
19.
Fallene Cotz Water Resistant Sunscreen for Sensitive Skin (SPF 58) (2006)
4
0
1
20.
Baby Blanket Sunscreen Stick for Babies, SPF/FPS 45+ (2007)
4
0
1
21.
California Baby SPF 30+ Sunblock Stick No Fragrance (2007)
1
1
1
22.
California Baby SPF 30+ Sunblock Stick Everyday/Year-Round (2007)
1
1
1
23.
KINeSYS KIDS Sunscreen Spray with Parsol 1789 (SPF 30+) (2006)
2
1
1
24.
California Baby SPF 30+ Sunscreen Lotion Everyday/Year-Round (2007)
2
1
1
25.
California Baby SPF 30+ Sunscreen Lotion Natural Bug Blend (2007)
2
1
1
26.
California Baby SPF 30+ Sunscreen Lotion No Fragrance (2007)
2
1
1
27.
Coppertone Endless Summer Ultrasheer Sunscreen Stick (2005)
3
1
1
28.
Vanicream Sunscreen for Sensitive Skin (SPF 30) (2006)
3
1
1
29.
Sea & Ski Platinum Sunscreen Lotion (SPF 50) (2006)
4
0
2
30.
ProCyte Z-Silc Sunblock (SPF 30) (2006)
4
0
2
31.
Elta UV Shield Daily Protection Oil Free (SPF 45) (2006)
4
0
2
32.
ProCyte Z-Silc Plus SPF 30& (2006)
4
0
2
33.
OBAGI NuDerm Healthy Skin Protection, AM (SPF 35) (2006)
4
0
2
34.
OBAGI NuDerm Healthy Skin Protection -Step Six (SPF 35) (2006)
4
0
2
35.
Peter Thomas Roth Ultra-Lite Titanium Dioxide Sunblock (SPF 30) (2006)
4
0
2
36.
DDF Organic Sunblock (SPF 30) (2005)
4
0
2
37.
DermaSpa Sun Protection (2006)
5
0
2
38.
Estion Sunscreen with Zinc (SPF 38) (2006)
5
0
2
39.
Coppertone UVA/UVB Sunscreen Lotion (SPF 30) (2005)
6
0
2
40.
Clarins Sun Care Cream For Children (SPF 30) (2005)
6
0
2
41.
Coppertone Spectra 3 Water Babies (Spf 50) (2006)
6
0
2
42.
Coppertone Spectra3 Sunblock Lotion SPF 50 (2007)
6
0
2
43.
Coppertone Kids Spectra 3 (Spf 50) (2006)
6
0
2
44.
Fallene Total Block Tinted Oil-Free Cover-Up (SPF 60) (2006)
6
0
2
45.
Dr. Brandt Body Barrier Gel (SPF 30) (2006)
2
1
2
46.
Peter Thomas Roth Max Tinted Protective Day Cream (SPF 30) (2006)
3
1
2
47.
TYK Soleil Tiempo Moisture Defense (SPF 25) (2006)
3
1
2
48.
PreSun Sensitive Cream Sunblock Cream (SPF 28) (2006)
3
1
2
49.
Topix Citrix Antioxidant Sunscreen (SPF 30) (2006)
3
1
2
50.
Baby Blanket Sunblock Lotion for Babies, Titanium Dioxide Formula (SPF 50) (2006)
3
1
2
51.
Lavera Sun Block Baby & Children SPF 30 (2006)
3
1
2
52.
Peter Thomas Roth Max Tinted Protective Day Cream with (SPF 30) (2006)
3
1
2
53.
California Baby Water Resistant, Hypo-Allergenic Sunscreen, SPF 30+ (2007)
3
1
2
54.
OBAGI NuDerm Sunblock 6, (AM) (SPF 24) (2005)
3
1
2
55.
PreSun Cream Sensitive (SPF 28) (2006)
3
1
2
56.
Olay Complete Defense Daily UV Moisturizer, Sensitive Skin (SPF 30) (2006)
3
1
2
57.
MD formulations Total Protector 30 Face (2006)
4
1
2
58.
All Terrain Aqua Sport (SPF 30) (2005)
4
1
2
59.
Ti-Silc GT Sunblock SPF 60& (tinted) (2006)
4
1
2
60.
M.D. Skincare Waterproof Sunscreen with Vitamin C (SPF 30) (2006)
4
1
2
61.
Solar Sense Face and Lip Protection Sunblock Cream (SPF 45) (2006)
4
1
2
62.
Institut DERMed Sun Protective Cream Oil-Free (SPF 25) (2006)
4
1
2
63.
South Beach Sun Sport Zinc Extreme Sunblock (SPF 50+) (2005)
4
1
2
64.
Mustela Bebe Moderate Sun Protection Lotion (SPF 25) (2006)
4
1
2
65.
MD formulations Men's Total Protector 30 (2006)
4
1
2
66.
Blue Lizard Australian Suncream SPF30+ Regular (2007)
4
1
2
67.
Physicians Formula Sun Shield Extra Sensitive Skin Sunblock (SPF 25) (2005)
4
1
2
68.
Neutrogena Sensitive Skin UVA/UVB Block (2005)
4
1
2
69.
NuCelle SunSense with Z-Cote (SPF 30) (2006)
4
1
2
70.
DCL UVA/UVB Chemfree Superblock (SPF 30) (2006)
4
1
2
71.
Panama Jack Surf 'n Sport Sunblock Lotion (SPF 75) (2005)
4
1
2
72.
MD formulations Total Protector Color 30, Light Tint (2006)
4
1
2
73.
No-Ad Sport Sunblock Lotion Waterproof (SPF 50) (2006)
4
1
2
74.
Neutrogena Sensitive Skin Sunblock Lotion SPF 30 (2007)
4
1
2
75.
Belli Anti-Chloasma Facial Sunscreen (SPF 25) (2006)
4
1
2
76.
Lavera Sun Spray SPF 30 Neutral * (2006)
4
1
2
77.
Olay Complete Defense Daily Uv Moisturizer (SPF 30) (2006)
4
1
2
78.
Blue Lizard Australian Suncream SPF30+ Sport (2007)
4
1
2
79.
Alba Sun Care Sport Sunscreen, Very Water Resistant (SPF 30) (old formulation) (2005)
4
1
2
80.
MD formulations Total Protector 30 (2006)
4
1
2
81.
OBAGI-C Rx System C SunGuard (SPF 30) (2006)
4
1
2
82.
Banana Boat Surf Sunblock Lotion with AquaShield H2O Protection (SPF 30) (2006)
4
1
2
83.
Olay Complete Defense Daily UV Moisturizer, Sensitive Skin (SPF 30) (2006)
5
1
2
84.
Coppertone Oil-Free Face (SPF 30) (2006)
5
1
2
85.
DCL Essential Skin Protection (SPF 30) (2006)
5
1
2
86.
SkinCeuticals Sport UV Defense (SPF 45) (2006)
5
1
2
87.
SkinCeuticals Ultimate UV Defense (SPF 30) (2005)
5
1
2
88.
Aveeno Baby Sunblock Lotion, Continuous Protection, SPF 55 (2007)
5
1
2
89.
Coppertone Spectra3 Sunblock Lotion (SPF 30) (2006)
5
1
2
90.
Juice Organics SPF30 Light Tint Moisturizer (2007)
5
1
2
91.
Coppertone Oil-Free Sunblock Lotion, Sensitive Skin (SPF 30) (2006)
5
1
2
92.
Juice Beauty Sheer Moisturizer (SPF 30) (2006)
5
1
2
93.
M.D. Forte Aftercare Environmental Protection Cream (SPF 30) (2006)
5
1
2
94.
Elta Gold UV Facial (SPF 30) (2006)
5
1
2
95.
Alba Sunscreen, Kids (SPF 30) (old formulation) (2005)
5
1
2
96.
Elta Swiss American Elta Gold UV Lotion Sunblock and Moisturizer (SPF 30) (2006)
5
1
2
97.
KINeSYS Sunscreen Spray with Parsol 1789 (SPF 30+) (2006)
5
1
2
98.
Juice Beauty Tinted Moisturizer (SPF 30) (2006)
5
1
2
99.
Solbar AVO (SPF 32) Lotion (2006)
5
1
2
100.
Elta Gold UV Lotion Sunblock and Moisturizer (SPF 30+) (2006)
5
1
2
101.
Somme Institute Double Defense Face and Body (SPF 30) (2005)
5
1
2
102.
Elta Swiss American Elta Block (SPF 32) (2006)
5
1
2
103.
Fallene Total Block Tinted Cover-UP (SPF 60) (2006)
6
1
2
104.
Neutrogena Uva/Uvb Sunblock Lotion (SPF 45) (2006)
6
1
2
105.
Neutrogena UVA/UVB Sunblock Lotion (2006)
6
1
2
106.
AVON SUN Baby Sunscreen Lotion (SPF 40) (2005)
6
1
2
107.
Blue Lizard Australian Suncream Lotion, SPF 30+, Face (2007)
6
1
2
108.
Dermalogica Ultra Sensitive FaceBlock (SPF 25) (2006)
2
2
2
109.
Mustela Moderate Sun Protection Stick (SPF 20) (2006)
2
2
2
110.
Kiss My Face Hot Spots Certified Organic Formula Sunscreen (SPF 30) (2006)
3
2
2
111.
CoverBlend Concealing Treatment Makeup, Terracotta Sand (SPF 20) (2006)
3
2
2
112.
ProCyte Ti-Silc Sheer (tinted) (SPF 45) (2006)
3
2
2
113.
ProCyte Ti-Silc Sheer Sunblock SPF 45 (2007)
3
2
2
114.
ProCyte Ti-Silc Untinted (SPF 45) (2006)
3
2
2
115.
PreSun Ultra Gel (SPF 30) (2006)
3
2
2
116.
Ti-Silc Sheer Waterproof UVA/UVB Sunblock (SPF 45) (2006)
3
2
2
117.
Baby Blanket Faces Sunblock Lotion for Babies (SPF 45) (2006)
3
2
2
118.
Kiss My Face Face Factor, Face & Neck (SPF 30) (old formulation) (2006)
4
2
2
119.
Cellex-C Water Resistant Sunscreen (SPF 30) (2006)
4
2
2
120.
Cellex-C Sun Care (SPF 30) (2006)
4
2
2
121.
Boscia Oil-Free Daily Hydration (SPF 15) (2006)
1
3
2
122.
Kabana Skin Care Green Screen SPF 15 All Natural Sunscreen - Unscented (2007)
1
3
2
123.
Badger SPF 15 (2007)
1
3
2